29, October 2026

In 2026 THECIS celebrates its 25th anniversary. To celebrate this, we are starting a 25th Anniversary Blog series where we ask prominent individuals to write a blog to provide perspective on a topic related to innovation and entrepreneurship. This Blog is by Brian Wixted.  During the 1990s, Brian worked for the Australian government on measures of innovation and agricultural science policy. In the early 2000s, he worked for a university research centre on innovation studies. After moving to Canada, Brian has been involved in large university research networks on cluster, city, and digital innovation systems together with various contract research projects. His major works have focused on the global architecture of trade. Brian has been a THECiS Fellow since 2005.

Blog 114:  40 years (Almost) Retrospective. A personal perspective

1989-1990.

When I started to work professionally in the field of what might be called Technology Economics for the Australian Government on the eve of 1990s the field was, looking back, at a hinge point in development.

At the beginning of the 1990s, measurement was of growing importance. The OECD was publishing influential books on indicators[i] and around the world there was work to develop reports on science and technology contributions to economic development. Data on industries and trade was becoming more accessible and comparable. Everywhere the gold standard on economic change comparisons was R&D intensity – the percentage an industry spent on R&D relative to Value Added.

There was a growing concentration of interest on industries of interest – aerospace (high technology), motor vehicles (medium technology) computing (high technology) and pharmaceuticals (high technology). High, medium and low were decided on terms of their expenditure on R&D compared to their value added.

Every issue of the journal Research Policy seemed to contain new and exciting ideas[ii].

Looking back from that hinge

The 1970s literature had been concerned with the cold war, “the future” and thus with industrial / research policy. For example, the abstract from Keith Pavitt’s article in Volume 1 of Research Policy might strike some as eerily familiar if more optimistic than the current status.

European fears in the 196O’s of U.S. technological domination have proved to be unfounded. The continuing U.S. lead in aerospace and defence technology has not spread to other sectors. European companies and governments have steadily upgraded their capabilities in civilian science and technology. … There remain, however, very severe imperfections in the utilization of Europe’s resources in the “‘strategic” technological sectors; communications, aerospace, energy[iii].

My assessment of the 1980s is more of growing academic-isation (read dataisation) and government policy professionalisation. More researchers, more data, more interesting ideas.

Looking forward from the hinge (the long 1990s)

The key issues of the 1990s in the field were the development of ideas of innovation systems (particularly national institutions) and clusters. For the study of what was now increasingly called innovation studies see for example Nelson[iv] or, Lundvall [v] and much more.

In the real world of technology two vast networks of technologies were developing almost simultaneously at that point in time: electronics (computing and the internet were a big deal) and biotechnology (particularly agricultural biotechnology) was also a promising emerging super technology ecosystem. Through the 2000s ideas of innovation systems and clusters continued alongside other systems (the triple helix model for example).

2010s – The second hinge

To me the mental algorithm of innovation studies which has always had close ties with innovation policy advice for governments, was this:

We understand the past and current patterns of innovation to inform innovation policy to create the future.

My personal view is that around 2010, to pick a date, a tear in the fabric of this algorithm begun – one that has just got wider ever since.

Academic studies necessarily look backwards for quality data and to understand in peer environments the phenomenon being studied. Around 2010 reality started to outpace the ability to study ‘innovation’. I think it is why THECiS as an organisation needed to pivot from innovation studies to entrepreneurship approximately 2013 and why there has been little consulting money for innovation ever since.

This wouldn’t be a blog about innovation without some categories so let’s invent some.

The First economy – the plain everyday economy (food, chemicals, energy, transport etc.). While everything is digitally connected for the sake of argument somethings are still grounded. It would take a book to explain the developing basis of technologies during this decade, but one example. In 2012 I attended a talk by a world leading expert on energy systems at the AAAS in Vancouver (Daniel Kammen). His focus was on coal because he did not believe solar would be competitive until well into the 2030s. In retrospect the data reveals solar became cost competitive with coal sometime between 2013 and 2019.

The Second economy (hybrid) – where the digital interlaces with the physical. Uber and Airbnb changing cities. Amazon changing retail. Mining in Australia in open pit iron ore sites going autonomous as early as 2008[vi].

The Third economy (completely online) – social media and streaming services.

The first economy has been downplayed or ignored, the second economy got some attention but the third grabbed the headlines (Facebook) while the world slowly changed.

2020s.

Do these few words fire the imagination.

First economy:  massive cargo and cruise ships, electric (battery) ships, drones, rocketry, EVs, electric flight, solar energy and so much more.

Second Economy: data centres, platform economy, e-commerce, autonomous mining (still), drone ships, robots, autonomous vehicle (taxis).

Third Economy: Streaming wars (Amazon buys MGM, Paramount buys Warner, Social Media, the AI economy etc.

Looking forward and policy issues

That will be the next blog.

 

[i] OECD (1989) OECD Science and Technology indicators No 3: R & D, production and diffusion of technology, OECD, Paris.

[ii] Robson, M. Townsend, J. and Pavitt, K. (1988) ‘Sectoral patterns of production and use of innovations in the UK: 19451983’ Research Policy 17 (1988) 1-14.

[iii] p210 Pavitt, K. (1971/1972) ‘Technology in Europe’s future’ Research Policy I (I971 / I972) 210-273

[iv] Nelson, R.R. (ed.) (1993), National Innovation Systems: A Comparative Analysis, Oxford, Oxford

University Press.

[v] Lundvall, B.-Å. (ed.) (1992), National Innovation Systems: Towards a Theory of Innovation and

Interactive Learning, London, Pinter Publishers. And see also Innovation System Research and Policy

Where it came from and where it might go Bengt-Åke Lundvall CAS Seminar, Oslo, December 4, 2007

[vi] See Wixted 2019 https://www.schoolofpublicpolicy.sk.ca/research-ideas/publications-and-policy-insight/policy-brief/innovation,-disruption-and-the-second-economy-of-mining.php